Urgent Interim Relief and Section 12A: Madras High Court in Aarthi Scans Private Limited v. Konica Minolta Business Solutions India Private Limited

Urgent Interim Relief and Section 12A: Madras High Court in Aarthi Scans Private Limited v. Konica Minolta Business Solutions India Private Limited

Urgent Interim Relief and Section 12A: Madras High Court in Aarthi Scans Private Limited v. Konica Minolta Business Solutions India Private Limited

07-November-26

When Can a Commercial Suit Skip Pre-Institution Mediation? Madras High Court Explains

A commercial suit that seeks urgent interim relief need not go through pre-institution mediation under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The urgency must be real from the plaintiff’s point of view, not a device to avoid mediation. Applying this test, the Madras High Court set aside an order of the Principal Commercial Court, Egmore, which had returned a plaint for want of mediation.

Aarthi Scans Private Limited v. Konica Minolta Business Solutions India Private Limited, C.R.P. No. 754 of 2026, decided on 27 February 2026 by Justice S. Sounthar.

The facts

Aarthi Scans had 127 printers supplied by Konica Minolta under a series of agreements executed between October 2023 and December 2024. Aarthi Scans said these agreements were signed without the approval of its Board of Directors and were therefore invalid. It terminated the arrangement with effect from 31 May 2025 and asked Konica Minolta to take the printers back.

According to Aarthi Scans, Konica Minolta neither removed the printers nor stopped raising invoices. The printers continued to occupy valuable commercial space at its premises.

Aarthi Scans filed a commercial suit seeking declarations, injunctions and damages of ₹27,43,200 for storage and demurrage at ₹3,600 per printer per month. Along with the plaint, it filed two applications for urgent interim relief:

  1. an injunction restraining Konica Minolta from raising invoices or payment demands from 1 June 2025, and
  2. a mandatory injunction directing Konica Minolta to remove the 127 printers from its premises.

On 3 February 2026, the Commercial Court held that the suit did not contemplate urgent interim relief and returned the plaint with a direction to first complete pre-institution mediation. Aarthi Scans challenged this order in revision.

The legal test

Section 12A divides commercial suits into two classes. Suits that do not contemplate urgent interim relief must go through pre-institution mediation. Suits that do contemplate such relief need not.

The High Court traced the test through four decisions:

  • M/s. Ganga Complex v. TSR Films Pvt. Ltd. (Madras High Court, 24 March 2023): Unlike Section 80(2) CPC, Section 12A does not require the plaintiff to obtain leave of the court. The burden on the plaintiff is light. If the plaint and the supporting affidavit show a need for urgent relief, the suit falls in the exempt class unless the prayer is illusory or a camouflage.
  • Yamini Manohar v. T.K.D. Keerthi, (2024) 5 SCC 815: The court must examine the nature and subject matter of the suit, the cause of action and the interim prayer, from the plaintiff’s standpoint. The plaintiff has no absolute right to bypass Section 12A, but the court’s role is limited.
  • Dhanbad Fuels (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, (2025) 9 SCC 424: The test is not whether the interim relief is ultimately granted. It is whether urgent relief could be said to be contemplated, viewed from the plaintiff’s standpoint.
  • Novenco Building and Industry A/S v. Xero Energy Engineering Solutions Pvt. Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2278: The plaint and its documents must disclose a real need for urgent intervention. Relevant factors include immediacy of the peril, irreparable harm, risk of losing rights or assets, and whether delay would make the final relief ineffective. A pro forma prayer used to skip mediation will be ignored.

In short, the court does not decide the merits of the interim relief at this stage. It asks only whether the urgency is plausible from the plaintiff’s point of view.

The decision

The High Court found that Aarthi Scans had clearly pleaded its difficulties. The printers were taking up commercial space, and invoices continued to be raised despite the termination. The interim reliefs sought were therefore not a camouflage to bypass Section 12A.

Whether the termination was valid, and whether the interim reliefs should be granted on merits, were questions for later. The Commercial Court had erred in returning the plaint at the threshold. The High Court directed it to number the plaint, if otherwise in order, and proceed with the suit.

The Court decided the revision without notice to Konica Minolta, because the plaint had been returned before numbering and the defendant had not yet been heard. For the same reason, it left Konica Minolta free to apply for rejection of the plaint for non-compliance with Section 12A after entering appearance. Any such application is to be decided on its own merits.

Practical takeaways

  1. Plead the urgency in the plaint itself. The court looks at the plaint, the documents and the supporting affidavit. Explain the concrete, ongoing harm, as Aarthi Scans did with occupied premises and continuing invoices.
  2. File the interim application with the plaint. A suit that genuinely contemplates urgent relief should show it on the day of presentation.
  3. Avoid a token prayer. Under Novenco, a pro forma or anticipatory prayer for urgent relief will be ignored, and the plaintiff will be sent to mediation.
  4. A return of the plaint can be challenged. Where a Commercial Court returns a plaint despite a genuine urgent prayer, a revision before the High Court is available.
  5. The issue can be raised again by the defendant. Clearing the threshold at presentation does not end the matter. The defendant may still seek rejection of the plaint under Section 12A.

Conclusion

The judgment is a practical reminder that Section 12A does not shut the door on businesses facing a real and continuing problem. Where the plaint shows genuine urgency, the suit can proceed without waiting three months or more for mediation.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

Arun Kumar Jambulingam is an Advocate practising before the Madras High Court and courts in Chennai.