Cheque Bounce Notice Received by a Family Member Is Valid: Supreme Court in Sainaba v. State of Kerala

Cheque Bounce Notice Received by a Family Member Is Valid: Supreme Court in Sainaba v. State of Kerala

Cheque Bounce Notice Received by a Family Member Is Valid: Supreme Court in Sainaba v. State of Kerala

14-November-26

Cheque Bounce Notice Received by a Family Member Is Valid: Supreme Court Settles the Question

A statutory demand notice under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 is validly served when it is sent by registered post to the drawer’s correct address, even if a family member receives it. The Supreme Court so held in Sainaba v. State of Kerala & Anr., 2026 INSC 1069, decided on 30 September 2026, and declared its earlier decision in M.D. Thomas v. P.S. Jaleel (2009) to be per incuriam.

The Bench comprised Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah and Justice Manmohan. The judgment was authored by Justice Manmohan.

The facts

The complainant lent ₹3 lakh to the accused, whose cheque was dishonoured. On 31 August 2016, the complainant sent the statutory demand notice by registered post to the accused’s correct address. The accused’s mother received it. The accused neither paid nor replied.

The Trial Court convicted the accused in July 2019, and the appellate court upheld the conviction in February 2023. In revision, the Kerala High Court set aside the conviction. It held that proviso (b) to Section 138 was not satisfied because the notice was received by the mother and not by the accused himself.

Why the notice was held valid

The Supreme Court relied on Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 and Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. Where a notice is sent by registered post to the correct address, the law presumes that it was served.

The key points of the ruling are:

  • Dispatch to the correct address raises a presumption of service. The complainant need not prove that the drawer personally received the notice, or that he deliberately evaded it.
  • The presumption is rebuttable. The burden shifts to the drawer to show that the address was wrong, that he had no knowledge of the notice, or that the postal endorsement was incorrect.
  • In this case, the accused had given the same address in his vakalatnama, his appeal and his revision petition, and in the summons served on him. He never disputed that address when examined under Section 313 CrPC.

The Court also held that the High Court, in its revisional jurisdiction, could not reappreciate the evidence and reverse concurrent findings of guilt, as those findings were neither perverse nor illegal. The appeal was allowed and the conviction restored.

M.D. Thomas declared per incuriam

In M.D. Thomas v. P.S. Jaleel (2009), a two-judge Bench had set aside a conviction where the notice was received by the drawer’s wife.

The Supreme Court held that M.D. Thomas was decided per incuriam, because it did not consider the earlier three-judge Bench decision in C.C. Alavi Haji v. Palapetty Muhammed (2007). Alavi Haji held that sending the notice by registered post to the correct address satisfies the requirement of “giving” notice, subject to the drawer’s right to rebut the presumption. As a decision of a larger Bench, it was binding.

What this means

For payees and complainants:

  1. Send the demand notice by registered post with acknowledgement due to the drawer’s correct and current address.
  2. Keep the postal receipt, the tracking record and the acknowledgement card. They are the basis of the presumption.
  3. Use the address in the cheque, the loan documents or the drawer’s own correspondence, so that it cannot later be disputed.

For drawers and accused persons:

  1. Receipt by a family member is not, by itself, a defence.
  2. A challenge to service must show something specific: a wrong address, a false postal endorsement, or genuine lack of knowledge of the notice.
  3. Under Alavi Haji, a drawer who claims he never received the notice can still pay the cheque amount within 15 days of receiving the court summons. Taking this step early can avoid a conviction.

Conclusion

The ruling closes a technical defence that had been raised in cheque bounce cases for over fifteen years on the strength of M.D. Thomas. What matters is whether the notice was properly sent to the right address, not which member of the household signed for it.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

Arun Kumar Jambulingam is an Advocate practising before the Madras High Court and courts in Chennai.