11-November-26
A US buyer who has paid an Indian supplier for goods that never arrived, arrived defective, or were short-shipped can recover the money in India. The route depends on one question above all: does the contract have an arbitration clause? This guide explains the options, in the order a US buyer usually needs them.
Before spending on litigation, confirm that the supplier is a real entity with assets in India. Three public records help:
If the supplier is a sole proprietorship, the claim lies against the proprietor personally. If it is a company, the claim lies against the company, and directors are generally not personally liable unless fraud can be shown.
A formal notice from an Indian law firm often changes the supplier’s attitude. It states the amount due, the basis of the claim and a deadline to pay. It also creates a record for later proceedings, including the date from which interest is claimed. Many disputes settle at this stage.
A US judgment cannot be executed directly in India. Under Section 44A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, only decrees from “reciprocating territories” notified by the Government of India can be executed as if they were Indian decrees. The United States is not a reciprocating territory.
The US buyer must therefore file a fresh suit in India based on the US judgment. The Indian court treats the judgment as conclusive, unless one of the exceptions in Section 13 CPC applies. These include a judgment given without jurisdiction, a judgment not on the merits (such as a default judgment entered without examining the evidence), and a proceeding contrary to natural justice. A suit on a foreign judgment must generally be filed within three years of the judgment.
Because of these exceptions, a US default judgment against a supplier who never appeared may carry limited weight in India. In such cases, it is often better to sue in India on the original claim.
This is usually the strongest position for a US buyer. India and the United States are both parties to the New York Convention, and India has notified the United States as a Convention country. A foreign arbitral award made in the US is enforceable in India under Part II of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
The buyer files a petition for enforcement before the High Court that has jurisdiction. The supplier can resist only on the limited grounds in Section 48, such as invalidity of the arbitration agreement, lack of proper notice, or conflict with the public policy of India. Indian courts do not review the merits of the award. Once the court holds the award enforceable, it is executed as a decree of that court.
Where the arbitration has not yet started, the buyer can also seek interim protection from an Indian court under Section 9 of the Act, such as an order restraining the supplier from moving its assets.
The buyer can file a commercial suit in India. A dispute arising from an export contract, with a value of ₹3 lakh or more, is a commercial dispute under the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The suit is filed where the supplier carries on business.
Key features for a foreign claimant:
The general limitation period is three years from the date payment fell due. A written acknowledgement of the debt by the supplier, signed within that period, starts a fresh period.
If the supplier is a company or LLP and the unpaid amount is ₹1 crore or more, the buyer may consider insolvency proceedings before the National Company Law Tribunal under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. A foreign creditor can file. This step exerts significant pressure, because the supplier’s management faces losing control of the company. However, it is not a debt collection tool, and an application will fail if there is a genuine pre-existing dispute about the claim.
Where the supplier took an advance with no intention of supplying, a criminal complaint for cheating may be possible under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. Indian courts have repeatedly cautioned that a commercial dispute cannot be converted into a criminal case. A criminal complaint should be considered only where the facts show fraud from the start, and never as a substitute for civil recovery.
The easiest dispute to resolve is one the contract has already planned for. For future purchases from India, include:
Recovering money from an Indian supplier is achievable. An arbitration award is the fastest route to enforcement, a commercial suit or summary suit works where there is no award, and a US court judgment needs a fresh suit in India. The right choice depends on the contract, the documents and the supplier’s assets, so early advice saves time and cost.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.
Arun Kumar Jambulingam is an Advocate practising before the Madras High Court and courts in Tamil Nadu, advising on commercial litigation and cross-border recovery.