12-November-26
Many US businesses win a judgment at home against an Indian party, only to find that it cannot simply be executed in India. The reason is a single provision of Indian law. Understanding it early can save a US claimant months of effort and a second round of litigation.
Under Section 44A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, a decree of a foreign court can be executed in India as if it were an Indian decree only if the foreign country is a “reciprocating territory” notified by the Government of India.
Countries notified include the United Kingdom, Singapore, the UAE, Malaysia, New Zealand, Hong Kong and Bangladesh. The United States is not on the list. A judgment of a US federal or state court therefore cannot be filed directly for execution in India.
A US judgment is not worthless in India. It can be used as the basis of a fresh civil suit, called a suit on a foreign judgment. The Indian court will treat the US judgment as conclusive on the matters it decided, provided none of the exceptions in Section 13 CPC applies.
Under Section 13, a foreign judgment is not conclusive where:
Under Section 14 CPC, when a certified copy of the foreign judgment is produced, the court presumes that it was given by a court of competent jurisdiction, unless the contrary is shown.
The suit must be filed within three years from the date of the US judgment.
Most US judgments against Indian suppliers are default judgments, entered because the Indian party never appeared. These are the weakest in India.
In International Woollen Mills v. Standard Wool (UK) Ltd., (2001) 5 SCC 265, the Supreme Court held that a foreign decree passed without the defendant appearing, and without any consideration of evidence, is not a judgment “on the merits” under Section 13(b). Such a judgment is not conclusive, and the claimant may have to prove the claim afresh in India.
A judgment is far more useful where the Indian party appeared and contested the case, or where the US court recorded findings on the evidence.
1. A foreign arbitral award. This is the most effective route. India and the United States are both parties to the New York Convention, and India has notified the US as a Convention country. A US-seated arbitral award can be enforced in India under Part II of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The Indian court does not review the merits. It can refuse enforcement only on the limited grounds in Section 48, such as invalidity of the arbitration agreement, lack of proper notice, or conflict with the public policy of India. Once held enforceable, the award is executed as a decree of the Indian court.
2. A suit on the US judgment. Where the US judgment was contested and decided on the merits, a suit on that judgment is usually quicker than proving the whole claim again. The key evidence is the certified copy of the judgment.
3. A suit on the original claim. Where the US judgment is a default judgment, it is often better to sue in India on the original contract. A dispute of ₹3 lakh or more arising from a business transaction is a commercial dispute, heard under the time-bound procedure of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The two claims can also be pleaded together in the alternative, so the claimant is protected if the court declines to treat the US judgment as conclusive.
In both suits, the court can attach the defendant’s property before judgment where there is a real risk of assets being moved, and a decree can be passed in foreign currency.
A US judgment does not open the door to execution in India, but it is not the end of the road. A contested judgment can support a fresh suit. A default judgment usually cannot, and the claim must be proved on its merits. The surest path for future dealings is arbitration, because India enforces foreign awards without reopening the dispute.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.
Arun Kumar Jambulingam is an Advocate practising before the Madras High Court and courts in Tamil Nadu, advising on commercial litigation and cross-border recovery.